New York City’s Democratic Socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Friday that he wants to close Rikers Island jail by 2032, and his plan to get there is exactly what you’d expect from a guy who calls himself a Democratic Socialist: let people out early and hope for the best.
It’s like if you were able to combine the “this is fine” and “what could possibly go wrong” memes into one giant clusterfunk – you’d get Mamdani and his boneheaded bad decisions.
Rikers is one of the world’s largest jail facilities, sitting on a 413-acre island between Queens and the Bronx that was, fittingly, once a garbage dump. It currently holds about 6,000 inmates, 2,500 of whom are long-term residents. The place has picked up colorful nicknames over the years, including Gladiator School, Torture Island, and the Oven. Nothing says “safe and humane correctional system” quite like a place called the Oven.
Mamdani’s scheme hinges on shrinking the inmate population down to around 4,500 through diversion programs, supervised early release, and expanding housing and social services. He’s also talking about restoring an online bail payment system and reducing case delays, though he has yet to explain where the money for any of this comes from. Just vibes, apparently. You can read more about Mamdani’s Rikers Island closure plan and what it would actually require under city law.
The city is also expected to brush aside a legal requirement that any closure of Rikers must be matched by four smaller, modern replacement facilities built by 2027. Laws are more of a suggestion when you’ve got a mandate from the progressive base, apparently. Even Mamdani’s predecessor, former Mayor Eric Adams, opposed the borough jails part of the plan, which is a pretty remarkable thing to have in common with Eric Adams of all people.
President Trump has already weighed in on Mamdani’s longtime dream of emptying Rikers, previously calling it, plainly and correctly, “not good.” Hard to argue with that analysis when the solution to a dangerous jail is to send the people inside it back into New York neighborhoods.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement. “For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane.” He also said the city has “a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers” and promised to work with the City Council, courts, and nonprofit partners to get it done.
What happens next is a battle over funding, legal requirements, replacement facilities nobody wants built in their borough, and the small matter of where 6,000 inmates go when the doors swing open. New Yorkers can rest easy knowing their Socialist mayor has a plan, he just hasn’t figured out who’s paying for it yet. Totally normal stuff for the city that never sleeps, or apparently never learns.



