USAJournal

The Right Views. The Right News.

VIEWS

NYC Mayor Mamdani Can’t Explain the Math on His City-Owned Grocery Store Plan

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani got cornered by CNBC's Andrew Ross Sorkin at the New York Times Dealbook Summit when he couldn't explain the basic economics of his city-owned grocery store proposal.

Text size

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani walked into what should have been a friendly interview at the New York Times Dealbook Summit on November 18 and walked out looking like a man who just discovered that math is real. CNBC’s Squawk Box co-anchor Andrew Ross Sorkin asked him a simple question about his city-owned grocery store proposal, and Mamdani had absolutely nothing.

Sorkin laid the trap calmly and politely. He pointed out that grocery stores typically operate on margins between one and four percent, and Mamdani’s plan calls for selling products at a 30 percent discount. Then Sorkin asked the obvious: “How is this going to work at all? Just walk through the math when you think about it?” He also helpfully reminded Mamdani, in case it had slipped his mind, that “the subsidy is coming from us, the taxpayer.”

Mamdani’s response was a masterpiece of saying nothing while using a lot of words. He compared city-owned grocery stores to subways, public schools, and libraries, arguing that “when society deems something necessary for the public, then we subsidize its creation and operation.” That’s a great argument, except that Mamdani city-owned grocery store plan it accidentally reminds everyone how well New York’s government-run operations actually perform.

Take public schools. According to an analysis by Empire Center President Zilvinas Silenas from September 16, New York spends roughly $90 billion on its public school system, about $37,000 per student, and fourth- and eighth-grade students’ math and reading performance has been declining. The New York Post editorial board reported in July that 906 out of 1,600 city schools are “perennial failure factories” that keep operating anyway and enroll about 43 percent of all NYC public school children. So yes, Zohran, the government grocery store model is very reassuring.

If you use Google, could you please add us to your trusted sources? Just tap the button below. It helps Google see how the readers enjoy our work. Thanks!



When Sorkin pressed him on the actual operational numbers, Mamdani didn’t answer. Instead he pivoted to a completely different question, saying, “In some ways that’s the question New Yorkers are asking themselves every day when they go to the grocery store: ‘Explain the math to me of how the same thing that I used to buy a couple of years ago has now skyrocketed in price.'” That would be a fine answer to a question about inflation, which is a problem caused largely by the kind of runaway government spending Mamdani apparently can’t get enough of.

CNN and other liberal outlets had been practically fanning themselves over Mamdani’s grocery store idea, so watching a CNBC anchor politely dismantle it in real time was a rare treat. Sorkin didn’t need to yell. He just asked Mamdani to do arithmetic, and that was enough.

Mamdani is still the mayor of New York City, which means this grocery store scheme isn’t dead yet. New Yorkers can look forward to more grand socialist proposals from their mayor, each one carefully designed to avoid any contact with how money actually works.

Watch Mamdani get beclowned on video:



This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Should Ilhan Omar be Deported?*
Email*
Submitting your answer to see results will subscribe you to our free newsletter. If you do not want the newsletter, then you can skip the poll. You may also unsubscribe anytime. Thanks!!


Frank

Kutztown University graduate who specializes in trending news and politics curation for USA Journal.