House Democrats are set to introduce legislation that would give immigrants with final orders of removal a path to legal permanent residency, as long as they have no criminal record. The bill, called the Protect Our Neighbors Act, is being led by California Democratic Rep. Lateefah Simon and was first shared with ABC News.
The legislation was inspired by the case of Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old grandmother who lived in the San Francisco Bay Area for three decades before being deported to India. ABC News reporter Juhi Doshi, who first covered Kaur’s case last year, broke the news of the bill on November 18.
Under the proposal, final orders of removal would expire 10 years after being issued for individuals who have been continuously present in the United States and have not been convicted of a crime. Currently, there is no expiration on final orders of removal. the Protect Our Neighbors Act bill details would also allow an immigration judge to renew an expired order if “clear and convincing evidence” showed significant cause for the delay in executing the original order, and if renewal is deemed in the public interest based on new evidence.
It’s worth clarifying how removal orders work in practice. While a final order of removal gives Immigration and Customs Enforcement the legal authority to deport someone, deportation doesn’t happen instantly. It can be delayed through government deferrals, stays of removal, ongoing litigation, or other circumstances.
Republican Rep. Brandon Gill pushed back sharply. Having a final order of removal means that an immigration judge has determined that you have no claim of asylum or legal right to be in America,” he wrote on social media. Gill added that “there’s literally no class of criminal illegal alien that Democrats won’t fight to keep in your community.
Kaur’s case drew attention partly because even judges on the Ninth Circuit, known as one of the more liberal federal appeals courts, ruled that she did not have a valid asylum claim, according to social media posts responding to the bill’s announcement.
The bill faces long odds. Republicans hold the House majority, and even if the legislation somehow advanced, it would almost certainly face a veto. No timeline for a floor vote has been announced, and the proposal is expected to function primarily as a messaging effort ahead of ongoing immigration debates.
What do you think about this bill? Share your thoughts in the comments below or weigh in on social media.



