Close Menu

Mamdani, AOC Seen Laughing At Ground Zero Ceremony And The Critics Are Letting Them Have It

VIEWS

For weeks, the families of the murdered asked one thing of the mayor of New York City: stay home. More than 100,000 people signed their petition. They delivered it to City Hall days before the anniversary. One relative put it about as plainly as a human being can — our people were killed, we don’t want him here, it’s disrespectful.

Zohran Mamdani went anyway. He announced he would remain at Ground Zero until every last name had been read. On Friday, as those names were being read, a camera caught the mayor and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez sharing a laugh. The clip was everywhere within the hour, and it will be in campaign ads within the week, because in the frame just before it a man is coming apart with grief.

Let’s be precise, since precision is what separates an argument from a hashtag. Nobody can hear what was said. A few seconds of video does not prove the two of them were mocking the dead, and anyone claiming otherwise is overplaying a strong hand. People standing in a long ceremony exchange words. It happens. That is exactly the point, and it is the point Mamdani was too arrogant to grasp.

WATCH:

The families understood something he didn’t: on that ground, on that morning, a politician is not a participant. He is furniture. His entire job is to stand still, keep his face composed for four straight hours, and let the names belong to the people who own them. Any mayor with an ounce of instinct knows that the risk of being there is precisely this — that one unguarded second in front of a lens becomes the permanent record. NYC Mayor (at the time) Rudy Giuliani, whatever else you think of him, understood the assignment. So did former Mayors Michael Bloomberg and Bill de Blasio, and that is a low bar cleared.

Mamdani weighed that risk against the photograph he wanted and chose the photograph. Now he has a different one. And this did not come out of nowhere. It arrived at the end of a month in which the mayor signed an executive order honoring the victims and then directed the ceremonial pen to Ramzi Kassem, his chief counsel, whose client list includes an al-Qaeda member convicted of war crimes and related by marriage to one of the hijackers. That was the gesture that launched the petition. It was a choice, made deliberately, on camera, and the families read it correctly.

So no — the laughing clip is not really the scandal. It’s the receipt. It is what happens when a man is told by three thousand families’ survivors that his presence would wound them, decides his own symbolism matters more, and then can’t manage four hours of solemnity to prove them wrong.

New Yorkers were told this administration would be about dignity for the forgotten. Turns out the forgotten are the widows in the third row, and the dignity was allocated elsewhere. He’ll issue a statement. It will be gracious and well-written and it will not matter, because the families already told him what to do and he already told them what he thought of it. Everything since has been commentary.

Remember this in November — not because a man smiled at a funeral, but because he was asked not to attend and could not conceive of a world in which his presence wasn’t the most important thing on the schedule.