When critics on Rotten Tomatoes dismiss a film while audiences celebrate it with enthusiasm, it highlights a disconnect between professional reviews and popular opinion. The recent box office hit Reagan is a prime example of this phenomenon. Released on August 30, the film charts the life of Ronald Reagan, from his modest beginnings in small-town America to his Hollywood career and eventual presidency.
Viewed through the lens of Viktor Petrovich, a former KGB agent whose path crossed with Reagan’s during the Cold War, the movie offers a compelling portrayal of a figure who captivated both Americans and his global adversaries. Despite critical disapproval, Reagan has struck a chord with audiences across the country.
Starring Dennis Quaid as Ronald Reagan, the biopic delves into the life of a man who triumphed over adversity, supported steadfastly by his wife, Nancy, portrayed by Penelope Ann Miller. The film’s engaging narrative, coupled with Quaid’s captivating performance, serves as a poignant tribute to one of America’s most esteemed leaders. Women’s rights in sports advocate Riley Gaines noted on X: “Just finished the Reagan movie. The whole theater burst into applause when it finished. Not a single person left during the credits where they showed actual pics of Reagan throughout his life. No one was more dedicated to fighting communism than Ronald Reagan. Go see it!”
Just finished the Reagan movie. The whole theater burst into applause when it finished. Not a single person left during the credits where they showed actual pics of Reagan throughout his life.
No one was more dedicated to fighting communism than Ronald Reagan. Go see it!??
— Riley Gaines (@Riley_Gaines_) September 2, 2024
Check out the trailer:
Despite its broad appeal among moviegoers, Reagan faced significant criticism from Hollywood professionals. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film received a mere 18% positive rating from critics, a stark contrast to its 98% audience score on opening weekend. CinemaScore, which gauges moviegoer satisfaction, awarded Reagan an “A,” placing it alongside blockbuster successes like Deadpool and Wolverine. This dramatic divergence between critical reviews and audience reactions highlights a notable disconnect between Hollywood insiders and everyday viewers.
The film’s success extends beyond audience approval, as it also made a significant mark at the box office. Reagan debuted in third place, earning $7.65 million over the opening weekend and reaching $10 million by the end of Labor Day from 2,754 theaters nationwide. This impressive performance is particularly notable given the competitive landscape of new releases. Despite the crowded field, Reagan was the only newcomer to break into the top five, demonstrating that audiences remain captivated by the story of one of America’s most iconic leaders.
“First off it was such a privilege. Probably the biggest privilege I’ve had as an actor really,” Quaid said about the role. “The response, before the movie came out, I’ve never really had that before.” Former exhibition veteran and current president of Showbiz Direct, Kevin Mitchell, expressed his excitement about the company’s successful debut. “We are thrilled to be sitting in the top 5 with our first movie in a competitive market over this holiday weekend,” Mitchell told Variety. He added, “We expect the film will continue to grow in the weeks ahead, especially in the South and Midwest.”
