USAJournal

The Right Views. The Right News.

NEWS

Samuel Alito Warns Court-Packing Could Change Supreme Court Permanently

Justice Samuel Alito warned that a campaign to intimidate justices or expand the Supreme Court could fundamentally alter the institution, possibly forever. He made the remarks while accepting an award at a Washington dinner.

Text size

Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito issued a stark warning this week that efforts to expand or intimidate the Court could change it permanently, remarks he delivered while accepting the American Enterprise Institute’s Irving Kristol Award at the institute’s annual dinner at the National Building Museum in Washington, D.C.

“It now appears that the Court may soon face a structural question of far greater magnitude: whether it will be allowed to continue as an independent tribunal that decides cases based on its understanding of the law, not political pressure,” Alito said during the event.

Alito described what he called a mounting campaign targeting the Court. “What we have seen in recent years is a mounting campaign to change the direction of the Court’s decisions by intimidating justices or, if that fails, by seriously damaging the Court’s standing in the eyes of the public and then altering the Court’s composition,” he said. “If that campaign succeeds, the Supreme Court as an institution will be fundamentally changed for many years, and perhaps permanently.” Video of the remarks circulated on C-SPAN and social media in the days following the speech, as covered in the Samuel Alito court-packing remarks.

If you use Google, could you please add us to your trusted sources? Just tap the button below. It helps Google see how the readers enjoy our work. Thanks!



Alito also pointed to the judiciary’s structural vulnerability. He noted that the courts lack both “the sword” of enforcement power and “the purse” of independent funding, making them dependent on the other branches. “Because presidents and members of Congress are elected, what may matter most in the end is popular support for an independent judiciary,” he added.

The comments come as Democrats prepare to take majorities in both chambers of Congress in January. Several Senate Democrats have backed legislation to increase the number of justices on the Court. Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts has sponsored the Judiciary Act, which would expand the Court from nine to thirteen members. Markey has argued the move would restore seats he claims were “stolen” from Democrats.

Senator Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island has been one of the more consistent voices for structural changes. In a 2019 amicus brief he joined with other Senate Democrats, Whitehouse and colleagues wrote that the Court “is not well” and suggested it could face public pressure to be “restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics.” Whitehouse has also backed ethics rules, term limits, and increased oversight of the Court.

None of the expansion proposals have been enacted. The Constitution leaves the number of justices to Congress, and the Court has had nine members continuously since 1869, following earlier changes during the 19th century. Whether any new legislation moves forward when the new Congress convenes in January remains to be seen. Share your thoughts on this story in the comments below or on social media.



This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Should Ilhan Omar be Deported?*
Email*
Submitting your answer to see results will subscribe you to our free newsletter. If you do not want the newsletter, then you can skip the poll. You may also unsubscribe anytime. Thanks!!


Jonathan Davis

Jonathan Davis is the editor-in-chief for USA Journal News.