USAJournal

The Right Views. The Right News.

VIEWS

Okay, The Number of Trump Voters Who Stayed Home For the Midterms Is Brutal

Text size

J.L. Partners has the first serious postmortem on November 3, and the numbers tell a cleaner story than two weeks of cable commentary have managed.

The firm surveyed 1,000 registered voters on Election Day and checked the results against more than 30,000 interviews conducted over the campaign. What they found: 35 percent of Donald Trump’s 2024 voters did not cast a ballot this month. Just 8 percent crossed over and voted for Democrats.

Do the arithmetic the way the pollsters did. The swing toward Democrats since 2024 was 15 points. Ten of those points came from Trump voters who stayed home. Five came from voters who switched. More than two-thirds of the Blue Tsunami was an absence, not a conversion.

That distinction is the whole ballgame, and it’s worth being precise about why.

If you use Google, could you please add us to your trusted sources? Just tap the button below. It helps Google see how the readers enjoy our work. Thanks!



A converted voter is a hard problem. Somebody who looked at this president’s record and decided a Democrat would do better has to be argued back, and the argument takes years. An abstention is a different animal entirely. Those 35 percent didn’t decide Hakeem Jeffries should run the House. They didn’t decide Gina Hinojosa should run Texas. They looked at the ballot, found no reason to drive to the ballot box on a Tuesday, and went to work instead.

They are still Republicans. They are sitting right there. They just have to be given a reason to cast a ballot. And here’s where the finding stops being comforting and starts being an indictment.

What reason were they offered? Senate Republicans held a majority for two years and produced one significant piece of legislation — making the 2017 tax cuts permanent, which prevented a tax increase — plus confirmations, which are the constitutional minimum. The SAVE America Act, backed by roughly eighty percent of the country, never got a floor vote because John Thune counted two dozen holdouts and decided the climb was too steep. The DHS funding fight dragged through the fall and gave candidates nothing but a mess to explain.

Conservative politico Larry O’Connor said it before the election and it still stings: Republican senators went home to their states without much to show.

So a working-class voter in Michigan or Ohio, who broke his routine in 2024 because he believed something would change, watched two years of nothing, and concluded the trip wasn’t worth it. That is not apathy. That is an accurate performance review.

The good news is real. A party that loses by abstention has a far shorter road back than one that loses by persuasion. Ten points of that fifteen-point swing is sitting at home waiting to be asked properly.

The bad news is that the people responsible for asking just reinstalled themselves by acclamation, in a closed room, five days after the wipeout, while their leader told colleagues he wasn’t apologizing for anything they did and didn’t know what else voters could want.

Here’s what they want: evidence that showing up accomplishes something. It’s really that simple. “Make Life Affordable Again.”

Give them that and ten points come home in 2028. Give them another two years of this and they’ll stay on the couch again — and the people who do show up will be the ones who think Don Lemon should be president.



This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Should Ilhan Omar be Deported?*
Email*
Submitting your answer to see results will subscribe you to our free newsletter. If you do not want the newsletter, then you can skip the poll. You may also unsubscribe anytime. Thanks!!


Jonathan Davis

Jonathan Davis is the editor-in-chief for USA Journal News.