The U.S. Senate voted 51-46 on Monday to confirm Daniel Domenico to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, making him the third Trump-nominated judge to join the Denver-based panel. Domenico had been serving as a judge on the U.S. District Court of Colorado and briefly held the role of chief judge there earlier this year.
President Donald Trump first nominated Domenico for the federal district court in 2017 during his first term. Trump nominated him again in May of this year for the appeals court seat, which opened when Judge Timothy Tymkovich announced he would retire as an active judge and shift to senior status. Domenico had clerked for Tymkovich back in 2003.
Both of Colorado’s Democratic U.S. senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted against the confirmation. A spokesperson for Hickenlooper said Domenico’s judicial record and his behavior during a committee hearing raised concerns about his fitness for a lifetime appointment. Notably, Domenico declined to answer when a senator asked him who won the 2020 election. Hickenlooper’s office said that refusal, combined with his record on immigration, “were troubling and inconsistent with the high standards we should expect from federal judges.”
You can follow the full details of the confirmation through the Domenico 10th Circuit confirmation coverage from Colorado Newsline.
More on Daniel Domenico 10th Circuit can be found in the original report from Colorado Newsline.
Bennet pointed to Domenico’s seven years on the district court as a source of concern, particularly a ruling he made earlier this year that said the federal government can detain immigrants without a bond hearing, a position that contradicted every other Colorado federal judge. “An appellate-level role on the federal circuit carries broader responsibility and greater consequence, making these concerns particularly significant,” Bennet said in a statement. He added that he could not support elevating Domenico “at a time when the Trump Administration has spent years undermining the rule of law and eroding the independence of the federal courts.”
The 10th Circuit hears appeals from district courts in Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas, New Mexico, Wyoming, Utah, and portions of Yellowstone National Park in Montana and Idaho. Its rulings can be appealed directly to the U.S. Supreme Court. Domenico joins Trump-appointed 10th Circuit judges Allison Eid and Joel Carson, both confirmed during Trump’s first term.
Before joining the bench, Domenico served as solicitor general for Colorado, arguing cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, the 10th Circuit, and the Colorado Supreme Court on behalf of the state across three governors. In 2022, he ranked fourth among all district and magistrate judges nationwide for the biggest backlog of pending motions.
Trump will now need to nominate a replacement for Domenico on Colorado’s federal district court. Colorado’s senators are typically part of that nomination process, which means Bennet and Hickenlooper will likely play a role in shaping who fills the seat. Share your thoughts on the confirmation in the comments below or on social media.



