USAJournal

The Right Views. The Right News.

NEWS

Mamdani, NYC Facing Major Lawsuit Over Attempt to Screw Amazon (and Consumers)

Text size

The socialists running New York City are looking at a major legal action over their obsession with screwing over Amazon, one of the country’s biggest online retailers and employers.

A coalition of New York business and civil rights groups is threatening legal action if the City Council approves legislation requiring Amazon and other major delivery companies to directly employ thousands of workers currently hired as independent contractors.

The dispute centers on the Delivery Protection Act, also known as Intro 518, which is backed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani and sponsored by Democratic Councilwoman Tiffany Cabán.

The proposal would effectively prohibit major delivery companies from using third-party contractors for key last-mile warehouse and delivery operations within New York City, as if that’s supposed to help consumers (it won’t – it’ll make delivery more expensive).

If you use Google, could you please add us to your trusted sources? Just tap the button below. It helps Google see how the readers enjoy our work. Thanks!



Attorney Derek Sells, representing the Five Borough Jobs Campaign and New York Delivers Coalition, warned Council Speaker Julie Menin that the legislation could violate federal and state law.

“My conclusion is that Intro 518 directly conflicts with existing federal and state law and raises serious legal questions about the city’s authority to enact it,” Sells wrote. He said his firm had been retained to evaluate possible litigation if the council moves forward.

“The legislation provides no compensation or meaningful recourse to the businesses it would eliminate,” Sells wrote. “If the City takes action that unlawfully and painfully destroys these businesses, those owners may have legal grounds to pursue recovery for the resulting losses.”

Sells urged lawmakers to eliminate provisions requiring direct employment, prohibiting subcontracting and mandating the rehiring of certain workers. “The city should not assume it can eliminate an entire industry of locally owned businesses without facing the financial and legal consequences of doing so,” he said.

Other groups have also joined in opposition to the legislation. Amazon operates its Delivery Service Partner model through more than 40 independent New York City companies employing more than 5,000 people. The company warned during an April council hearing that passage could force it to reconsider its operations inside the city.

“If enacted as written, Introduction No. 0518-2026 would directly undermine that commitment by threatening the more than 40 local small businesses we partner with to deliver to Amazon customers and the jobs of the more than 5,000 people they employ,” Amazon said in testimony.

The company said potential responses could include relocating delivery operations and facilities outside New York City.

Supporters dispute claims that the legislation would destroy jobs, but none of them are business owners and none of them really care much for Amazon in general, as evidenced by the fact that the original Democratic Socialist, AOC, helped kill an Amazon relocation project that would have employed 25,000 New Yorkers.

Mamdani endorsed the proposal in August, arguing that large corporations use subcontractors to avoid responsibility for workplace conditions – a complete nonsensical argument, since corporations use subcontractors because it saves them – and customers – money.

The mayor said the legislation would “rein in the power of corporate delivery giants like Amazon, hold them accountable for their exploitative business model and make New York City’s streets safer for workers, drivers and pedestrians.”

Under the legislation, operators of last-mile warehouses would be required to obtain two-year licenses from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Companies would face new requirements involving safety training, employment practices and worker protections, all of which would add to the cost of delivery and would be passed onto consumers.

What’s more, Mamdani and his band of socialists have not provided any evidence that Amazon is “exploiting” anyone, much less making NYC streets “unsafe.”

City estimates indicate approximately 45,500 warehouse and delivery workers could fall within the legislation’s broader regulatory framework.

Menin has indicated that changes remain possible.

“It’s time for Amazon to adhere to a licensing framework that ensures fair pay, strong worker protections, and more responsible delivery practices that don’t leave vehicles idling on our streets for hours,” Menin said previously.

“I am determined to pass a bill that both protects these workers and keeps these jobs in our city. We can and must do both.”

If lawmakers pass it without significant changes, opponents are signaling that the battle over New York City’s delivery industry could quickly move from City Hall into the courts. But then, when you vote for socialists, you get socialism. Good luck, New York.



This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Should Ilhan Omar be Deported?*
Email*
Submitting your answer to see results will subscribe you to our free newsletter. If you do not want the newsletter, then you can skip the poll. You may also unsubscribe anytime. Thanks!!


Jonathan Davis

Jonathan Davis is the editor-in-chief for USA Journal News.