The Department of Justice has issued more than 200 subpoenas in its criminal investigation into the so-called “Decoy Dan” scheme in Alaska, and a law enforcement source says Democrat Mary Peltola winning the Senate seat changes absolutely nothing about the probe. Nothing. Zero. The investigation is rolling on and there are multiple criminal targets across multiple states.
Here’s the quick backstory. Peltola just beat Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race, winning 144,302 votes to Sullivan’s 131,844. A fourth candidate, Dan J. Sullivan, a non-party affiliated guy with a suspiciously familiar name, pulled in 4,760 votes. That’s “Decoy Dan.” Allegations have swirled that Democrats deliberately recruited someone named Dan Sullivan to run against the Republican Dan Sullivan, purely to confuse voters and bleed off just enough support to tip the race. If that sounds like something out of a bad political thriller, well, welcome to modern Democrat campaign strategy.
High-profile Democrat attorney Marc Elias, whose law firm represents the Peltola campaign, is among those who received a criminal target letter from the DOJ earlier this month. Elias, the man who seems to show up wherever Democrats need creative election lawyering, is now a named target in a federal criminal investigation. Shocking. Truly shocking. Almost as shocking as the sun rising in the east. You can read more about the Decoy Dan criminal investigation and how the DOJ probe has expanded across state lines.
There are also whispers that Gerald L. Heikes, the fourth candidate on the ballot listed as a Republican who pulled 6,105 votes, may have been recruited as well, though that hasn’t been confirmed as a subject of a subpoena yet. The word “yet” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.
As for Decoy Dan himself, he went AWOL about a week before Election Day and hasn’t been seen since. There are rumors he’s hiding out in deep blue Colorado. The man allegedly helped tilt a U.S. Senate race and then vanished into a liberal state like a magician’s assistant. Incredible professionalism.
Now, the hard truth is that even if the DOJ investigation uncovers something serious, there’s no clear constitutional process for overturning a state election result. And if Peltola were somehow forced to step down, her replacement would be appointed by Alaska’s new Democrat governor, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins. So Democrats may have engineered a situation where they win coming and going.
Alaskan Republicans also need to wake up fast on ranked-choice voting. The repeal effort failed this cycle, and Democrats have clearly figured out how to exploit the system. Alaska now has both a Democrat governor and a Democrat senator, and RCV almost certainly made both possible. Republicans need to learn to play the game, because Democrats already wrote the rulebook.
The investigation will keep churning, and every time Peltola stands for office, this cloud follows her right to the ballot box. Sometimes winning isn’t exactly winning.



